Wednesday night of this week was dark and rainy, the air threaded with chill. In the late afternoon, I stopped by Whole Foods on my way home from a day filled with meetings, hoping to be inspired with an answer to the age-old quandary of What to Make for Dinner.
I had a large-ish chunk of roasted lamb in the refrigerator, left over from the night before, and I wanted to use it up. As I steered my cart through the produce section, it occurred to me that I should make a simple pasta sauce with fresh vegetables and tomatoes, cooked just until their juices began to leak into the pan, punctuated with nuggets of lamb, all heaped atop a tangle of fresh pappardelle and smothered in shavings of Pecorino.
Satisfied with this vision, I dropped a bright green fennel bulb to my cart, followed by a couple of carrots. An onion. A few organic shiitake mushrooms. A pint of cherry tomatoes. A wedge of Pecorino, chalky-white.
Hours later, I finally got around to making said sauce. I sizzled the onions and carrots in olive oil, added a handful of minced garlic, tossed in diced chunks of fennel. Grated salt and pepper over the top. Stirred. Inhaled the sweet, rooty aromas. Smiled.
Chopped up the shiitakes, whack whack whack. Threw them in the pan. Stirred. Walked away for a second.
When I returned, the scents wafting out of the pan had changed, and not just a little bit.
My first thought: forest floor.
You know you’ve been in a tasting room of some dimly-lit Napa Valley winery (or, in my case, the edge of a bar in a restaurant where a wine rep is pouring out his or her latest vintage with the hope that you’ll add it to the list) when the person across the counter leans across and murmurs sweet nothings in your ear: Ripe fruit. New French Oak. Hints of leather. Forest floor.
You and I have both nodded, snug in the embrace of a muscular Zin or a silky Cabernet. Forest floor good. Forest floor yummy.
Until that same forest floor is scooped up and added to your pasta sauce. Then it doesn’t taste, or smell, quite so delectable. Being the optimist that I am, I forged on and added the lamb, hoping against hope that my nose was playing tricks on me.
It wasn’t. While the rain drummed against the windows, I choked down a few bites, unwilling to admit that I might as well be eating a pile of partially-decomposed leaves mixed with dirt. And so ended my most recent Wednesday evening.
It will be a few weeks before I’ll be able to trust another shiitake mushroom.